Exhibit E · Case File 002-B · Supplement

Follow the foreskins.

I can’t find mine. So I went looking for everybody else’s.

Everything here happened, or is marked where I couldn’t confirm it. Sources are stapled to each folder. This picks up where Case File 002 left off, in a shoebox.

1 The Disposal

The Disposal

Presumed Discarded
Route A
The bin
Filed as
Pathological waste
Route B
The ground
Filed as
Yoreh De’ah 265:10
National count
Nobody keeps one

Start with the boring answer, because it’s probably the right one. Human tissue removed in surgery is generally classed as pathological waste. Depending on the state, that means an incinerator, burial or some other approved method, handled by a licensed company with a truck.

How many go this way? Nobody publishes a count. Every explainer I could find says most of them, and not one of them shows its work. So the stamp says presumed.

The other route is a good deal older. Jewish law says to bury it in earth or sand, and that has been in writing for more than nine hundred years.

When they would circumcise the babies, they would cover the foreskin with dust.

Maḥzor Vitry, late 11th century, citing Pirke de-Rabbi Eliezer 29

It went into the Shulchan Aruch, the standard code. Most mohels carry a small vial of earth so it can be done on the spot. There is even a verse to say while you do it.

THERE WAS A PROCEDURE.

I have my differences with the procedure that comes right before that one. But somebody thought about where it goes. A person was assigned. There was dirt on hand. As far as I can tell, I got a bin.

Stapled to this file: Daniels Health: pathological waste Posen Library: Maḥzor Vitry Din Online: burying the orlah Rabbi Solomons, on the vial

2 The Dowry

The Dowry

Paid in Full

Before there was a biotech industry, there was a king who wanted a hundred.

Buyer
King Saul
Asking price
100 foreskins
Delivered
200
In exchange for
His daughter, Michal
Consent
None on file. Any of it.

And Saul said, Thus shall ye say to David, The king desireth not any dowry, but an hundred foreskins of the Philistines, to be avenged of the king’s enemies.

Wherefore David arose and went, he and his men, and slew of the Philistines two hundred men; and David brought their foreskins, and they gave them in full tale to the king…

1 Samuel 18:25, 27

Saul set the price hoping the Philistines would kill David while he collected. The verse says so. David brought double. “In full tale” means the full count, so at some point in the history of the monarchy, a man had that job.

SOMEBODY COUNTED.

Other destinations on record:

Thrown. Exodus 4:25
Zipporah, the wife of Moses, “took a sharp stone, and cut off the foreskin of her son, and cast it at his feet.” The verse does not say whose feet. The son was not consulted.
Stockpiled, presumably. Joshua 5:3
“And Joshua made him sharp knives, and circumcised the children of Israel at the hill of the foreskins.” That is the name of the place, in the King James. There is a hill. Nobody will give me coordinates.
Ascended, allegedly
Thirty-one churches, one shoebox, possibly Saturn. See Case File 002.

Stapled to this file: 1 Samuel 18 Exodus 4 Joshua 5

3 The Fee

The Fee

Not a Sale

Everybody online says hospitals sell them. Nobody could show me a receipt. So I went looking for one.

Program
Tissue Donation Program
Company
Organogenesis
Hospital
Tufts Medical Center
Contract section
“Compensation”
Line item
“Tissue Sample Fee”
Amount
Missing

Organogenesis makes Apligraf, the skin graft in the next folder. In 2021 Anthony Losquadro, who runs an anti-circumcision group called Intaction, used state public-records requests to get internal Organogenesis documents, including contracts with hospitals in Massachusetts and Iowa.

The Tufts contract has a section called “Compensation,” which refers to a “Physician’s Payment Schedule,” a “Tissue Sample Fee” and an “Institution’s Payment Schedule.” The schedule with the amounts per foreskin was, in Losquadro’s words, “mysteriously missing.” Paragraph 8 is a confidentiality clause.

Tufts’ spokesperson confirmed that the hospital takes part in Organogenesis’ Tissue Donation Program, said it is “managed by strict IRB, ethics committee, and HIPAA regulations,” and sent further questions to Organogenesis. Organogenesis didn’t call back.

Those are an activist’s documents, so here are a university’s. Penn’s skin research core publishes its prices. For fiscal 2025 it lists a “Normal human foreskin acquisition fee (for culture)” of $47.25 for Penn researchers. The year before, outside researchers were charged $208.49.

Notice it’s always a fee. The law cares about that word. Trading skin “for valuable consideration for use in human transplantation” is a federal crime, punishable by up to $50,000 and five years. But “reasonable payments” for “removal, transportation, implantation, processing, preservation, quality control, and storage” don’t count. Research and face cream aren’t covered at all.

Nothing I found says anybody broke that law. That’s what bothers me. Nobody has to.

IT’S NOT A SALE. IT’S A FEE.

Stapled to this file: Losquadro, 2021 Penn price list, FY2025 Penn outside pricing, FY2024 42 U.S.C. § 274e Commercial Appeal, 1996

4 The Factory

The Factory

FDA Approved

This is the folder I wanted to be angriest about. It went badly.

Product
Apligraf
Made from
“Human infant foreskin”
Approved
May 22, 1998
Yield
200,000 units per foreskin
Signature
The mother’s

Apligraf is a living skin graft, grown in a lab and shipped to surgeons. The FDA’s approval order says what’s in it: “viable allogeneic human fibroblast and keratinocyte cells isolated from human infant foreskin.”

A company spokesperson told Wired in 1998 that “the cells from a single foreskin can produce 200,000 units of manufactured skin.” A trade publication later counted more than 250,000 units shipped, “every one grown from just 11 donors.” Somewhere there are eleven grown men who have been applied to a quarter of a million wounds. As far as I can tell, nobody told them.

How much skin is that? A company VP put it at up to two football fields per donor, because the cells are “so young, so robust, so full of life.” A report in a dermatology journal said five to six.

IT’S JUST A LITTLE BIT OF SKIN.

Now the part that ruins it. These work. They go on leg ulcers and diabetic foot ulcers, wounds that weren’t closing. In 2021 the FDA approved another one for severe burns, grown from “a line of skin cells called keratinocytes taken from foreskin tissue.” I looked for a way to be angry at a burn graft and I don’t have one. Nobody has to give up a foot for my grudge.

But if anyone ever offers you this as a reason to keep cutting, I have one word for them, and it’s eleven.

Stapled to this file: FDA: Apligraf approval order Wired, 1998 Wired, 1999 MassDevice: eleven donors Cap Times: StrataGraft

ONE
Not to scale. It can’t be.
5 The Catalog

The Catalog

In Stock

You can’t buy mine. You can buy these.

Catalog no.
SCRC-1041
Line
HFF-1
Tissue
Skin, foreskin
Donor age
Neonate
Donors
Two, pooled
Price
$256.00

The American Type Culture Collection sells a line called HFF-1. It was “established by ATCC in 2003 from normal human foreskin pooled from two individuals.” It was $256 the day I looked, and nonprofits may qualify for a discount.

Two individuals, pooled. They have never met. They have been in a freezer together for more than twenty years. They are at least twenty-three now, out there somewhere, with jobs.

Thermo Fisher has the single-donor version: “isolated from neonatal foreskin,” at least half a million cells, $788 a vial. The listing gives the donor’s age as:

14 DAYS OR LESS.

Some of what they get used for:

Raising stem cells
Human embryonic stem cells need a bed of support cells to grow on, called a feeder layer. It used to be mouse. In 2003 two labs showed foreskin works too, in papers with titles like “A culture system using human foreskin fibroblasts as feeder cells allows production of human embryonic stem cells.” ATCC sells HFF-1, the line above, as feeder stock: catalog no. SCRC-1041.1, “growth-arrested by irradiation with 6000 rads.” The most argued-over cells in medicine were raised on a bed of irradiated newborn foreskin. I don’t remember that being part of the debate.
Making stem cells
In 2007, James Thomson’s team in Wisconsin was one of the first two to turn ordinary human cells back into stem cells. They used “human newborn foreskin.” It’s in the paper. Nobody thanked it.
Toxoplasma
The parasite you can catch from cat litter. From a standard lab manual: “Human foreskin fibroblast (HFF) cells have been widely used to culture and maintain T. gondii tachyzoites.” A cat parasite currently has the use of a foreskin. I do not.
THE RELIC TRADE NEVER STOPPED. IT GOT A CATALOG NUMBER.

Stapled to this file: ATCC: HFF-1 Thermo Fisher: HDFn Hovatta et al., 2003 Amit et al., 2003 Cellosaurus: HFF-1 IRR Embryo Project: Yu et al., 2007 Current Protocols: Toxoplasma

6 The Spa

The Spa

Moisturized

This is where the trail goes somewhere I did not have string for.

Product
TNS Recovery Complex
Endorsed by
Oprah
Made from
One foreskin, says the company
Sold
To Allergan, 2012, ~$350 million
Donor’s cut
None on file

SkinMedica’s TNS Recovery Complex is sold at dermatologists’ front desks. The first ingredient is “Human Neonatal Fibroblast Conditioned Media.” A European patent application describes it as culture medium from a line of dermal fibroblasts “originating from neonatal foreskin.”

It came out of the skin graft business. In 2002 a business paper reported that its growth factors were “derived originally from neonatal human foreskin at the San Diego biotech Advanced Tissue Sciences,” the company behind Dermagraft, which developed and tested it with SkinMedica’s founder. Six years earlier, a Memphis paper had reported where those foreskins came from: ATS “asks new parents to sign a consent form donating it to ATS.” A retailer’s FAQ for the cream still tells the story:

Selected neonatal foreskins have been donated by parents to help burn and wound victims.

Skin Etc., product FAQ for TNS Recovery Complex. A face cream.

Then it got a celebrity. Oprah featured it on her show, and the press quoted her calling it a “magic fountain of youth and miracle wrinkle solution.” In 2013 the Canadian Foreskin Awareness Project picketed her tour in Vancouver, Ottawa and Montreal. Its founder asked the Toronto Star how she would respond “if a skin cream for men hit the market that was made using cells from the genitalia of little girls.” She didn’t comment. I would also like a comment.

The company said the cells came from a single foreskin obtained more than twenty years earlier, not from new circumcisions. Its founder had told a San Diego paper in 2010: “Initially, there was a misunderstanding and people thought we were actually grinding up the foreskin. So, there was a lot of snickering and laughing about people putting this foreskin product on their face.” The label doesn’t say it.

IT WON’T SAY FORESKIN.

In 2012 Allergan, the Botox company, bought SkinMedica for about $350 million. The donor’s cut is in Folder 7. It’s short.

The cream isn’t the only one. Sandra Bullock went on Ellen and said that she and Cate Blanchett are fans of what they call the penis facial. It’s a real service at the Georgia Louise Atelier in New York: a chemical peel, microneedling, a mask, and a serum with epidermal growth factor. IFLScience reported that the serum was “developed from the progenitor cells of the human fibroblast taken from Korean new-born baby foreskin.”

A representative wanted it understood that “the EGF serum only contains cloned cells.” I would like to know who that was meant to comfort.

Dr. Matt Zirwas, on growth factors in skin care: “good for marketing, and totally worthless when it comes to actual results.” In fairness, Zirwas says they do help when combined with microneedling, and this one has microneedling. I said I’d be fair. It hurt.

Last, the one that puts two good causes in the same room. EpiDerm is lab-grown human skin, sold since 1993, that companies use to check whether a product irritates skin without putting it on a rabbit. Its maker calls it “a reliable and ethical alternative to animal testing.” Its maker also describes it as “based on neonatal foreskin-derived normal human epidermal keratinocytes.”

CRUELTY-FREE.

The rabbit had a lobby.

Stapled to this file: Skinsort: the ingredients Patent EP3437650A1 OC Business Journal, 2002 Commercial Appeal, 1996 Skin Etc.: the FAQ HuffPost: Oprah, 2013 Philadelphia: her words CBC: the founder Allergan, SEC filing HuffPost UK IFLScience MatTek: EpiDerm MatTek: the cells IIVS: the test it replaced

7 The Paperwork

The Paperwork

No Claim

So whose is it? I looked it up. There is case law.

Case
Moore v. Regents
Court
California Supreme, 1990
Tissue
A spleen, mostly
Held
Not his
Also held
They had to tell him

John Moore was a leukemia patient at UCLA. His doctors took his spleen, kept taking samples, and in 1984 the university got a patent on a cell line made from him, called Mo. He sued for a share.

In 1990 the California Supreme Court ruled that Moore had no ownership of his cells once they were out of him, and no right to a share of what got made from them. It did say his doctor should have told him about the money. He settled for what the Los Angeles Times called a token amount.

Moore was an adult, awake, and able to sign things. That is the high-water mark.

Henrietta Lacks wasn’t asked at all. In 1951, doctors at Johns Hopkins took cells from her tumor without her knowledge. They became HeLa, the first human cells to keep reproducing in a lab indefinitely, and they have been used in research all over the world ever since. In 2021 her estate sued Thermo Fisher for profiting from them. The company said it doesn’t sell HeLa cells. They settled in 2023, on confidential terms.

That case was national news, and it should have been. Thermo Fisher is also the company with the $788 vial in Folder 5, from a donor “14 days or less” old. I’m not aware of anyone ever suing on behalf of one of those.

Federal research rules protect “human subjects.” Take the name off the tissue and it generally stops being one. Regulators proposed requiring consent for leftover, de-identified samples. The final rule, in January 2017, dropped that.

For the skin grafts there was a form. Wired, 1999: “The mother of the newborn must be tested for infectious disease and give permission for doctors to use the foreskin of her newborn.” The trade press has them as “donated by the mothers.”

So there is a signature on file. It just isn’t mine. I couldn’t hold a pen.

ITEM 2: NOT RECOVERED.

As for mine, that was the summer of 1990, and I don’t know which of these happened to it. Most likely it’s ash. It could also be in a freezer somewhere, doing more with its life than I have. The chart could not be located.

Stapled to this file: Wikipedia: Moore v. Regents KCAS: the 2017 rule CBS: the Lacks settlement Endpoints Wired, 1999 MassDevice

Court of public opinion · Case 002

The People v. THE RELIC TRADE

  1. Two hundred thousand units. One owner.
  2. Now with a catalog number.

Pull a folder. They all went somewhere.

Folders opened: 0 of 7 · Coffee: cold · Sleep: 0 hrs