Exhibit E · Case Studies

Case studies.

People keep telling me this was normal. I pulled the records. They’re right, and that’s the problem.

Everything in these folders happened, or is marked where I couldn’t confirm it. Sources are stapled to each file. I have had a lot of time.

001 Me

Me

Do Not Forget
Subject
Infant. (Me.)
Age at incident
0
Item 1
One (1) dress. Smocked. Bears.
Item 2
The snip.
Consent
None on file.
Status
Open. Very open.

Statement of grievance. The subject, aged zero, was placed in a smocked dress without consultation. A second matter was settled the same week. The subject was asleep for that one. No forms were signed by the subject. The subject could not hold a pen.

The dress. Green and smocked, with a white collar and three bears on the front. Somebody thought this was a good look for a boy and then got out a camera.

The circumcision. Same week, at the hospital. I slept through it, and that part of me is gone now. Gone where? As far as I can tell we aren’t even Jewish, so I’d still like to hear the reasoning. People say it’s in the Bible. I checked.

Everything else. Those are the two I can prove. Everything else got decided the same way, by people who were sure they knew best and were, to be fair, the only ones in the room who could talk.

THEY SAID THEY LOVED ME.

Stapled to this file: The Wall The Jury The Gallery

Enhance.
3 witnesses.
No shoes. No say.
002 The Holy Prepuce

The Holy Prepuce

Still Missing
Subject
Jesus of Nazareth
Age at incident
8 days
Item
One (1) foreskin. Allegedly.
Consent
None on file.
Known locations
Up to 31. Some simultaneous.
Status
Reported stolen, 1983.

You would think this one would be hard to misplace. Over the centuries, as many as 31 churches across Europe claimed to have the foreskin of Christ, sometimes at the same time. I have spent decades looking for one foreskin. These people had a surplus.

Charlemagne claimed an angel delivered it during prayer. A duller account calls it a wedding gift from a Byzantine empress. I would like it noted that neither of these is how you’re supposed to come by one.

In 1900 the Vatican reportedly got tired of the questions and threatened to excommunicate anyone who wrote or spoke about it. I am writing about it.

The best-known one stayed in Calcata, a village in Italy, until 1983, when the local priest reported it stolen, jeweled case and all. The priest had been keeping it in a shoebox. It is unclear whether any of them still exist.

FOLLOW IT WHERE??

Stapled to this file: Wikipedia: Holy Prepuce Il Post, in Italian: the decree and the shoebox

Missing

No photo
on file

One (1) holy foreskin

Last seen: a shoebox, Calcata, Italy, 1983
Answers to: God
Reward: excommunication

try Saturn

Court of public opinion · Case 002

The People v. THE RELIC TRADE

  1. Thirty-one foreskins. One owner.
  2. Losing the last one.
Supplement · 002-A · 6 folders From a Christian Perspective People keep telling me it’s in the Bible. It is. I kept reading. Supplement · 002-B · 7 folders Follow the Foreskins I can’t find mine. So I went looking for everybody else’s.
003 The Cereal Doctor

The Cereal Doctor

No Anesthetic
Suspect
John Harvey Kellogg, M.D. (1852–1943)
Employer
Battle Creek Sanitarium
Known for
Corn flakes.
Also known for
This.
Anesthetic
Withheld. On purpose.

You know the name from the box. Before there was a box, Dr. Kellogg published a health manual with a long section on stopping what the book calls “solitary vice,” which means exactly what you think it means. I read it so you don’t have to. Here is the recommended remedy for small boys.

A remedy which is almost always successful in small boys is circumcision, especially when there is any degree of phimosis. The operation should be performed by a surgeon without administering an anaesthetic, as the brief pain attending the operation will have a salutary effect upon the mind, especially if it be connected with the idea of punishment, as it may well be in some cases.

J. H. Kellogg, M.D., Plain Facts for Old and Young (1881)

Read the last part again. The doctor is recommending the pain.

THE CORN FLAKES GUY??

There’s a card on my wall that just says then WHY??? This is part of the answer. No single doctor did this alone, and nobody at my hospital was quoting Kellogg. But somebody taught somebody who taught somebody, and eventually somebody had scissors.

Stapled to this file: The whole book, Project Gutenberg Photo: Library of Congress, 1914

Dr. John Harvey Kellogg in 1914: an older man with a white mustache and beard, in an academic cap and gown. DR. KELLOGG
Suspect Alibi: “a salutary effect upon the mind”

Court of public opinion · Case 003

The People v. DR. KELLOGG

  1. Prescribing pain as a teaching tool.
  2. Corn flakes.
004 The Bone Doctor

The Bone Doctor

Standard Procedure
Suspect
Lewis A. Sayre, M.D. (1820–1900)
Specialty
Orthopedic surgery. Bones and joints.
Patient
Boy, 5. Could not walk.
Treatment
Circumcision
Promotion
President, American Medical Association

1870. A five-year-old who can’t walk is sent to an orthopedic surgeon. A colleague wants the leg tendons cut. Sayre decides the legs are paralyzed, notices the boy also has a tight foreskin, and concludes that one is causing the other.

I know how that sounds. I have a corkboard.

Sayre circumcised the boy. Within about two months the boy was walking. Five more boys followed, up to age 15, and the results went into the Transactions of the American Medical Association as “Partial Paralysis from Reflex Irritation.”

For nearly thirty years, doctors in the U.S. and England followed Sayre’s lead, using circumcision against paralysis and other nervous disorders. The paper was one of the first widely read medical arguments for doing it at all. In 1880 the AMA elected Sayre president.

Suspect No. 3 on my wall has an alibi: “standard procedure.” Somebody had to go first.

Stapled to this file: Embryo Project Encyclopedia Wikipedia: Lewis Sayre Photo: about 1875

Dr. Lewis A. Sayre, around 1875: a man with swept-back hair and heavy side-whiskers, in a dark coat and white bow tie. DR. SAYRE
Suspect Alibi: “reflex irritation”
LEGS FORESKIN
Sayre’s theory, reconstructed.

Court of public opinion · Case 004

The People v. DR. SAYRE

  1. Connecting things that were not connected.
  2. Telling the other doctors.
005 The Dress Code

The Dress Code

Precedent

The defense keeps citing Roosevelt. Fine. The defense can have company.

The Hemingway family in May 1900. At left, Grace holds Ernest, ten months old, in a white dress. At right, Clarence holds Marcelline, two, in a nearly matching white dress.

Ernest Hemingway

Dressed by: Grace Hemingway

Dressed alongside an older sister, Marcelline, as if they were twin girls, in fancy dresses and flowered hats, until at least age five. Grace also held Marcelline back a year of school so the set would stay together. Nobody asked Marcelline either.

Later Nobel Prize in Literature, 1954

source: Open Culture photo: 1900

Douglas MacArthur at about age four, around 1884, with long hair and a skirted kilt suit, leaning against his older brother, who wears short trousers.

Douglas MacArthur

Dressed by: Mary “Pinky” MacArthur

Unconfirmed. Kept in skirts until age eight, according to what my source calls “a highly reliable source”: Uncle John’s Legendary Lost Bathroom Reader. My source is a West Point class trivia quiz. The class split evenly between skirts and knickers.

Later Five stars

source: the quiz photo: about 1884, via HistClo

Rainer Maria Rilke at about age three, in 1879, wearing a frilled white dress and a dark hat, standing beside a carved table.

Rainer Maria Rilke

Dressed by: Sophie Rilke

Named René Maria by a mother who had lost a baby daughter. Sometimes addressed as Fräulein, Margaret or Sophie. Given dolls. Dressed as a girl until five or six, depending on who is telling it.

Later The Duino Elegies

source: Lapham’s Quarterly photo: 1879

In fairness to the suspects, small boys wore dresses for about four hundred years. The defense brings this up a lot.

Combined outcome of the above: one Nobel Prize, five stars and the Duino Elegies.

I have a domain name.

Court of public opinion · Case 005

The People v. THE MOTHERS

  1. Three boys. Zero fittings requested.
  2. Flowered hats.
Supplement · 005-A · 6 folders Why Boys Wore Dresses The full four hundred years, so that nobody has to bring it up to me again.
1965–2004006 John/JoanDavid

John/Joan

This one is the actual case study. There are no jokes in this file.

David Reimer was born in Winnipeg in 1965, one of identical twins. At seven months, a circumcision referred for a medical reason went badly wrong. The injury could not be surgically repaired.

The parents took their child to John Money, a psychologist at Johns Hopkins who believed gender was largely learned. Money’s team persuaded them to have surgery done and to raise the child as a girl. The surgery happened at 22 months. Nobody told the child why.

Money reported the case as a success. For years, doctors knew it as “John/Joan.”

It was not a success. By about age nine, Reimer was already saying so. At 14, Reimer’s parents finally explained what had happened. Reimer took the name David and lived the rest of that life as a man. Both twins later described being traumatized by their visits with Money.

In 1997, Reimer told the story to the sexologist Milton Diamond, who reported the outcome to discourage anyone from doing this to another infant. Brian Reimer, the twin, died in 2002. David Reimer died by suicide in 2004, at 38.

What happened to me is a photo and a grudge. I’m not comparing them. This file is here because it is what it looks like when everyone in the room is sure, and the patient is a baby.

No verdict. No vote.

Sources: Wikipedia: David Reimer John Colapinto, As Nature Made Him (2000)

If this file is close to home: in the U.S. or Canada, call or text 988. Anywhere else, findahelpline.com lists who to call.

Pull a file. They’re all bad.

Files opened: 0 of 6 · Coffee: cold · Sleep: 0 hrs