Exhibit E · Case File 005-A · Supplement

Why boys wore dresses.

The defense keeps saying this was normal. It was, for about four hundred years. Here is the whole file, so that nobody has to bring it up to me again.

Everything here happened, or is marked where I couldn’t confirm it. Sources are stapled to each folder. This is the long version of Case File 005.

1 The Custom

The Custom

Standard Issue
Practice
Boys in dresses until “breeching,” their first trousers
In effect
About the 1540s to about the 1920s
Territory
Europe and North America
Subjects
Boys, from birth to somewhere between 2 and 8
Timing set by
Usually the mother
Garment gender
Child

People call this a Victorian thing. It isn’t. It started around the 1540s, and the Victorians only got the last stretch of it. They are just the ones who owned cameras, so theirs are the pictures you have seen.

Before about 1550, plenty of grown men wore long robes, so a boy in one wasn’t a separate category. The custom only exists once men’s legs come out.

The important part is what the dress meant. It did not mean girl. It meant small. Jo Paoletti, the historian who wrote the book on American children’s clothes, found that telling little boys from little girls wasn’t considered important. Telling children from adults “seems to have been very important.” A dress put you on the children’s side of that line. Trousers got you across it.

IT MEANT SMALL.

The Victoria and Albert Museum says small boys from better-off families “had been dressed in their early years in exactly the same dress as girls.” Exactly the same. An 1895 Ladies’ Home Journal supplied the instructions: “A boy of two can wear dresses made from the same pattern as for a girl.”

“Better-off” is doing some work in that sentence. Portraits survive of people who could pay for them. Much less is known about working-class boys, for whom breeching may simply have marked the start of work.

Stapled to this file: JSTOR Daily, on Paoletti V&A: Hayter miniature, 1800 Cornell Costume Collection Wikipedia: Breeching Paoletti, Pink and Blue

2 The Wardrobe

The Wardrobe

A boy’s clothes were a ladder. This is how it ran in America from about 1890 to 1920, per Paoletti. The exact ages moved around by family and decade.

Stapled to this file: JSTOR Daily, on Paoletti Wikipedia: Shortcoating

  1. Birth to walking

    Long white dress. Boys and girls alike.

  2. Walking to 2 or 3

    Short, loose dress. The long ones made walking impossible. The move up is called shortcoating.

  3. To about 5 or 6

    Dress, or a suit with a short skirt. Color, material and trim start to differ.

  4. 5 to about 12

    Breeched. Short pants, usually in a costume: sailor suit, or velvet and lace.

  5. About 12

    Long trousers. A man, apparently.

3 The Motive

The Motive

Several

Nobody passed a law. Ask why and you get several answers, and most of them are probably a little true.

Toilet training
The one everybody repeats. Wikipedia calls it the main reason, and then that sentence carries a “citation needed.” I relate to that sentence.
Fastenings
Early breeches did up in complicated ways. There was no point in them until a boy could work them himself.
Money
Clothes were expensive. A dress is easier to make with room to grow, and easier to sew than a very small suit.
Hand-me-downs
A dress could go to the next baby, whatever the next baby turned out to be. Museum London, in Ontario, holds a plain white one worn by both of Lila Shaw’s sons between 1877 and 1888.
Superstition
A lingering belief that disguising a boy kept him safe from malevolent forces. It did not work on me. They got me the same week.

Stapled to this file: JSTOR Daily Wikipedia Museum London: the dress Sterne, Project Gutenberg

Transcript: a breeching conference, held in bed

We should begin to think, Mrs. Shandy, of putting this boy into breeches.

We should so,—said my mother.—We defer it, my dear, quoth my father, shamefully.

I think we do, Mr. Shandy,—said my mother.

Not but the child looks extremely well, said my father, in his vests and tunicks.

He does look very well in them,—replied my mother.

Laurence Sterne, Tristram Shandy (1761). Fiction. It only works as a joke if everyone reading has had this conversation.
4 The Ceremony

The Ceremony

Witnessed

First trousers got a word, breeching, and an audience.

The V&A calls it “a proud family occasion.” In the nineteenth century a boy might be taken to have his picture made in the new trousers, typically with his father. He might go around the neighborhood showing them off and collecting small gifts of money. Here is a grandmother, describing one in 1679:

Never had any bride that was to be dressed upon her wedding-night more hands about her, some the legs and some the armes, the taylor buttn’ing and other putting on the sword, and so many lookers on that had I not a ffinger amongst them I could not have seen him.

Lady Anne North, letter to her son, 1679. Quoted in Susan Vincent, Dressing the Elite (2003), p. 59

The boy’s father was away, and she had decided he should have “a full relation.” Note the sword. The child went in wearing what she calls “coats” and came out armed.

It was also a handover. The mother generally decided when, and advice columns were full of mothers asking whether it was time. After it, the father often got more involved. One exhibition review calls it “the ceremony of entry to the masculine world.” The hair tended to go around then too.

Stapled to this file: Wikipedia JSTOR Daily Digital Childhoods Library Company of Philadelphia

5 The Witnesses

The Witnesses

Conflicting

How old was a boy when this ended? I asked around.

WitnessPeriodAge
Costume SocietyGeorgian England3 to 6
Digital ChildhoodsGeorgian EnglandAround 6
FIDM MuseumEarly 1870sSkirts under 5
Museum London1880s Ontario5 or 6
Smithsonian18846 or 7
Library CompanyAbout 19005 to 7, around starting school
PaolettiBy 1900Past 2 or 3 was getting rare
Wikipedia19th centuryFalling to 2 or 3
WikipediaAll of it2 to 8

Finding: two to eight. It depended on the family, the decade, and how grown the boy looked to his parents. Nobody was checking.

Stapled to this file: Costume Society Digital Childhoods FIDM Museum, “Boy’s jacket and vest, 1870–1874” Museum London Smithsonian Library Company JSTOR Daily Wikipedia

6 The Victorians

The Victorians

Expired

Their part of it, and how it ended.

1837
Victoria takes the throne. The custom is already about three hundred years old.
1846
Her son Bertie, four, gets a sailor suit. Her diary: “Bertie put on his sailor’s dress, which was beautifully made by the man on board.” Winterhalter paints him in it. It “launched a thousand imitators.”
Early 1870s
The advice: skirts for boys under five, the kilt very much included. Knickerbockers from five to ten. Long trousers from about ten.
1884
Franklin Roosevelt, two and a half, is photographed in a white skirt. See my wall.
1886
Little Lord Fauntleroy. Black velvet, lace collar. Not a dress. This is what you got breeched into. A stage version in 1888 makes it a craze. “Many a boy in the [eighteen]nineties was seared by this weird pestilence.”
About 1900
Boys in dresses past two or three are getting rare. Mothers are advised “not to keep their boys in skirts too long.”
1901
Victoria dies. The custom outlives her.
After 1918
Dresses on boys die out, except for babies.
1920s
Rompers, for both. Trousers alone no longer mark a boy, and a dress now means girl.
1936
“Little Lord Fauntleroy” works as an insult, along the lines of “sissy.”

Why it stopped is still argued over. Mass production put more clothes made for children in the stores. Paoletti’s argument is that as women’s clothes turned more androgynous, children’s turned more sex-typed, and boys’ changed most of all. Once a dress stopped meaning small and started meaning girl, you couldn’t put a boy in one without saying something.

Which brings me to the defense’s favorite argument. Yes, small boys wore dresses for four hundred years. That precedent expired decades before anybody photographed me.

SMOCKED. THREE BEARS.

Stapled to this file: Royal Museums Greenwich: the suit Royal Collection: the portrait Digital Childhoods Smithsonian FIDM Museum: Fauntleroy JSTOR Daily Review of Pink and Blue Cornell Costume Collection Anna Wilson, “Little Lord Fauntleroy: The Darling of Mothers and the Abomination of a Generation” (1996)

Court of public opinion · Case 005

The People v. THE MOTHERS

  1. Three boys. Zero fittings requested.
  2. Flowered hats.

Pull a folder. It was all perfectly normal.

Folders opened: 0 of 6 · Coffee: cold · Sleep: 0 hrs